Normal Game Thread Mafia Lovers #1

A better thing to say would be "I would vote X, who is the wolfiest player".

 

Player list:-

1- @Cow
2- @BilboSwaggins
3- @Schpittfeuer - 2 Votes
4- @Crispickle - 2 Votes
5- @Coffee Cat
6- @Globear

Day Phase 1 ends in 30 Minutes! :-

>CountDown<

 

So there's a tie between Schpit and Cris.

All though it might be a good idea to keep it at that, I don't think we're gonna get anywhere in this game if we don't take a chance.

It's annoying that Schpit isn't here to defend for himself, which makes voting for him kinda hard.
However if I have to pick between Cris and Scpit, I feel Schpit is more likely to be mafia.
Cow seems too convinced that Cris is bad, but hasn't come with anything concrete that convinces me that foul play is at hand. Tbh I don't trust either of them, but Cow just seems a bit too eager to make Cris a suspect.
Then there's the fact that Bilbo didn't come with a valid reason (at least not in my opinion) to choose his victim.

I might be wrong, but I'm starting to suspect that Bilbo and Cow might be in on this together, considering their limited interactions with each others and how they throw shade over one person, without investigating others that thoroughly.
For me that's super suspecious, but since none of them are on the chopping board I'm not gonna vote for them.
I am however gonna question them more in the next DP.

The same reasoning as used above can be used on Schpit, since he hasn't provided a lot of content, which could imply that he's trying to hide so he doesn't have to answer too many questions, that might make him slip up and say something he shouldn't.
As i said before he sometimes becomes unsure and when he does, he doesn't say anything. Which he might have been adviced to do as well by his comrade.

However if my suspecion I mentioned about above, then Schpit is surely a townie.

Fu** this is hard...

You know what, I'm gonna take a chance and vote for Schpit and if he turns out to be town, then I'm pretty convinced that Bilbo and Cow are mafia.

For me it's down to those three, whom I think are most likely to be mafia atm and if we just get one of them then town wins.

Vote: Scpittfeuer
Reason: What I mentioned above

@Rohan

 

Because I think we need a lynch one way or another, Im going to go ahead and change my vote. Schpit doesnt seem too suspicious to me, but having a tie during the first day on this particular game doesnt seem like a good idea. I just hope @Coffee Cat and @Globear are correct.

@Rohan
Old vote: Crispickle
New vote: Schpittfeuer

 

Day Phase 1 has ended. Results will be out soon.

 

Vote Tally:-

1- @Cow
2- @BilboSwaggins
3- @Schpittfeuer - 4 Votes
4- @Crispickle - 1 Vote
5- @Coffee Cat
6- @Globear

@Schpittfeuer has gotten a majority of 4 votes. He was lynched by everyone.

@Schpittfeuer was a Vanilla Townie.

Player list:-

1- @Cow
2- @BilboSwaggins
3- @Schpittfeuer - Vanilla Townie
4- @Crispickle
5- @Coffee Cat
6- @Globear

Day Phase 2 has begun and ends in 1 Day, 23 Hours and 48 Minutes.

>CountDown<

(Giving one day extra time cause I will be busy for two days).

 

:

 

Why would you lynch a player who you believe will not flip wolf?

 

Because, like I said, I didnt think the game would go anywhere without a lynch. I didnt have any suspicions towards Schpitt, but I thought it would be necessary

 

Why not, instead, try to convince the other players in the game to vote a player who you believe is a wolf? What did we lose no-lynching there?

 

... well.

a good thing i'm alive but, hmm, it didn't go quite as hoped.

i don't get bilbo's switch either. It'd have been ok if you had an even vague suspicion on schpitt, but lynching him when you felt he was town is... why

 

Because, if Ive learned anything after having played mafia with both @Coffee Cat and @Globear, I know Im not skilled enough to convince either of them to change their votes

 

Yam it =.=. Although i shod have known we weren't going to get it right the first time
5 : 3/2
So we have to get mafia this phase or we'll be skating on thin ice

Bilbos vote was a bit iffy and i want to hear more from him but im not about to put all my attention onto him. Then if he's town we're screwed because we spent the whole dp on bilbo

Didn't he have the majority without you? Wht neessary?

Yeah although it's a bit of an obvious mafia move if he stated he had no suspicion so i dont know =.= ive learnt the people that make mistakes and slipups nornally aren't mafia

Musings i wouldnt say thats true at all =.=
It's not really about skill.

 

I don't think he did. Unless I missed something. Had I seen that he already had the majority vote, I wouldve kept my vote.

And I mean, I'm no good when it comes to persuasion. I figured it would simply be better to change my vote and get the lynch over with by changing my vote than it would to try to spend the last 30 minutes trying to convince someone to change sides

 

It says he has 4 votes at the end so.

But it just brought more attention to you