Normal Game Thread Elsword Mafia Game Thread

Because people lie in this game and I have no way of knowing if you actually were going based on your intuition or whatever. It looks like a very strange reason to throw up a vote on someone, especially considering you previous narrative that you don't want a lynch D1.

 

I agree. I am in favor of lynching D1, but I know some people don't agree with that so I consider it largely NAI.

@Ansatsuken, what is your experience playing Mafia?

 

It bcus Prada told me the move of abstaining is a move that Scum would do and better to mislynch than nothing happen(mean no one die) so we can get something from it(like a clue etc), from his experience. So I took his advice as I believe he could be a townie. But I changed my vote after reading SK self defense posts.

 

I think I can see where the issue lies here.
Basically I told you to vote right? You saw SK's wagon and wanted to jump on because it was the most obvious choice at that point (a lot of people on it). That being said you didn't make your mind up at that point, I guess. Hence you later voted for Nick against Sk when you made up your mind.

Keep in mind. Don't vote without proper reason. Make up your own opinions. Then post your vote with them included. People will then debate your points or agree with them.

 

@Quick
The more I read from Ans I get the feeling he is just a newbie. That being said I don't grasp his thing on SK where he said that I am free to lynch him this dp.

 

IIRC, you voted Nick to tie the vote and then Ratchet had to unvote to keep a lynch happening. Why would you tie in that situation? It seems inconsistent yet again for you to 1) just believe Prada and vote for ~someone~ based on nothing and then 2.) Tie the vote later giving a much better chance at No-Lynch because it forces someone else to have to do something about it. Why did you wait so long to vote for Nick? Why didn't you unvote SK when you started Town reading him instead of switching your vote to someone else like less than an hour left in EOD? Also, you didn't give a reason for voting Nick when you DID vote them, why not?

 

You are free to lynch who? SK or Ans?

 

My experience playing mafia

-Have people(Mafia) blend in very well to the point he sounds and looks exactly like a townie. Investigating, make a case for someone so that would leads to the lynching of that player.

-Many times I found a players who expressing themselves that they are a townie in their last effort self defending posts before they die, in the end they were found as a townie in the writeup result. Many mustakes I made here by not reading them very well.

-I dont know how far is the truth. Prada said when mislynch is happen in the first DP the town success rate is high. He said All games town won in the end. But in my experience yes in my mafia I participated in the past, First DP kill always happen but thats not mean town will win the game. It ends with mixed result. Stupid mafia lost oftenly. The ratio is 50:50.

My mafia game always started with 4 phases for the first round=intro, NP, DP, and lastly LP.

This is the second time actually I play mafia that start in DP and only have 2 phases.

 

Ok! Firstly, I think "given how things went last dp" and my conversations with certain people and what they said/what I wanted, it should be pretty easy to find me in the write up and work out who I am. That's all I will currently say on that

Alright so, it's either the leech thing I was talking about, but they're clearly on the same path here, I don't think they've truly brought the heat to each other and have questioned each other at all, even if you don't think that person is scum, so early in the game it's a pretty silly move, in fact they even try and stand up for one another and say "well lookie here", it doesn't look good honestly.


Originally, I wanted to push to specifically get Prada lynched - he's rather iffy in my mind, but now I'm really more curious about three players,
1- Ratchet
2- Quick
3- Ansa

I mean right now SK is boring to me now, I mean

By the way I just woke up so im not gonna quote a bunch of posts per person
1- Ratchet

I don't like the fact, that he went on and on about SK, and was really strongly feeling he was mafia, then as soon as that wasnt an option went for a no vote just for a lynch, even though he didn't even spend a fraction on the time he spent on Nick that he spent on SK. And now we lost two townies, and at least i've missed a post, he doesn't seem overly concerned, and would rather spend the time comparing game counts &.&
At this point he seems a little narrow minded, rather then taking in the whole game only focusing on one part, and rereading the thread my opinion hasn't changed, it's like he gets a goal and that's all he cares about, becoming oblivious to the rest of the game.

2- It's more just general opinions here, but he comes on and starts judging people on their game count? I think that's silly, it's really not going to help us get mafia and you just waste everyone's time. He asks like he knows everything about anything and I just don't like that playstyle, it seems really iffy to me, but considering i've never played a game with him here, it's not worth lynching

3- Ansa...where do I begin.

He says I don't provide a reason for voting or changing my posts, but I either do, or you can literally see in the posts and conversations around, it seems like he doesn't have his own opinion or plan at all, and seems to want to do whatever someone else says right now, which is almost as bad as the Ratchet/Prada allies thing. This means that it seems he doesn't really have his own opinion, it's just "he told me this, he told me to do that lalalalalala"

Can't decide who I want to pressure first really, which sucks, I originally intended to try and focus most of this dp trying to find out more from the Double Trouble, but, I'm not about to ignore other suspicions either, that's just whatever.

 

Oh I forgot something

@SK what is your thinking now?

What do you think of

Ratchet, Quick and Ansa in this current dp.

 

He said, if I get enough supports I am free to lynch SK.

@Rise-Chan where are you at?

 

@Ansatsuken
I have never won a game where the town abstained dp1 as town
I have won games where town lynched dp1 as town
That doesn't mean that a dp1 lynch ensures a win. It's just makes a win way more likely.

 

I am asking how many games (roughly) have you played. Where you typically play, it sounds like its pretty normal to Lynch D1, is that correct?

 

It bcus I'm not knowing very well how Prada/Ratchet playing in his community so unless I get some example I will playing using my own playing style as I dont really trust his playing style 100%. It could be a trap for a naive players.

For the decision to vote at last minute:-

I'm busy at work. When this place was very active I'm on my job so I have little time to read all the essay posts. You know it takes time. After I'm going home from my work I had a chance to read all the post properly helped by slow problematic internet connection and signal. Very frustrated. Within less an hour left for the DP to end I managed to sent the new vote.

 

You're right, that doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

I'll keep trying to sort Ans.