Normal Game Thread Big Trouble in Little Salem

Getting caught up. On page 5.

 

Anyways guys going to bed now

 

Ever heard of the tell too scummy to be Scum? Could be what's going on with Nick and the "role fishing". I have never actually seen Scum rolefish fwiw.

Good post.

Like this one too.

 

Their tone is different and they have since made points that I don't see them doing as Scum.

Bolding indicates confidence and a clear message. They were the only one to bold their innocents. I look at these kinds on things as Town to form reads, deal with it.

 

wdym their tone is different she just said hello and made a generic post about the game opening mm

I have a habit of bolding my innocents as it makes it easier to find when making lists.. Has really nothing to do with the fact that I'm town. You looking at tiny non-details is really off-putting though.. You're throwing around reads without properly reasoning them. That's not exactly town-like and thus pretty hard to deal with

 

Don't do pre-flip, it misses far more often than it hits.

 

Tbh have no idea why prada defended me.We didn't even speak at all. Props to him for doing though.

 

People questioned my Nigen read last time too and I was right there. Just because YOU do not have confidence in my methods doesn't make them any less correct. I do this all the time as Town and I am right more often then I am wrong when I do.

 

Why it seems probable to me that ningen and crimson falcon might be teaming up? obviously everything is just speculation at this point since it's only phase 1 and we're really just grasping at straws.

 

Scum get lynched D1 all the time and its not just because of random chance every single time it happens. D1 is not worthless.

 

Yeah but information is still very limited tho.

 

This depends entirely on HOW you get reads. If you are like me and have things like word choice, tone and behavioral cues in your toolbox, its not as limited as one might think. The reason some players say D1's are worthless is because they use things like VCA and analyzing kills. I don't do that very much so it doesn't effect my reads too much.

 

That sounds pretty different from you getting worked up about cf and ningen calling you scum.

Not sold on any of the lynches, so going to do it in the morning if it's needed.
Was mostly considering Globear, because I really don't like how she entirely disappeared after talking about CR a little (especially because it was mostly being 'forced' to by Prada's quoting) and got ignored until Quick randomly came by to call her town without providing a good reason. Based on last game, inactivity as scum seems to be a thing for her and she was p active in the forum but not posting late.
Dunno what to make of the CR situation yet and if I can excuse all of his poor logic/ interactions and scummy behavior with inexperience, so holding it off at the moment.

 

I didn't get worked up lol :mihawk Just defending myself from baseless accusations. Saying things like he was frustrated or nervous is simply silly. Just more ungrounded assumptions to prove me guilty. Simply put it that way, I jokingly say I'm scum, everyone attacks me and now suddenly I'm the suspect. Is that what you deem as rational logic?

 

Would it actual be role fishing then if you think this way? I mean town would role fish unless they were certain the person was scum. Obviously I would not know that. So only scum would do such. I'm not I get the statement or your stance on this. If I'm role fishing then I'd be scum pretty much or terrible town. Or maybe it was a joke.

Ps it was the latter.