Normal Game Thread Big Trouble in Little Salem

Good to start again!

I read as town by the way

Also anyone that gets sick of defending themselves in mafia immediately goes to my watch list, be it a ss game, assassin game or whatever

 

So, if I tunnel someone into getting pissed you will scumread him? Great logic there Globear

I also investigate as innocent

 

No but if someone is just like
"I dont wanna, cant be bothered, or screw you all" it's like why wouldnt they want to defend themselves?

 

You realise that you can weight such things differently. If I tunnel you for 2 dp's you gonna get sick of it as well.

 

Truth but we are three-four pages in

 

So why even bring it up then?

 

I was just commenting on what i read. Why else?

 

I mean u tunnled SK for two dp last game

Hmm glob I'll keep my eye on her for time being,

 

SK deserved that tunnel tho. Until I confirmed him he never really deserved a town read.

 

I investigate innocent

You insist on using the same logic when it's already been explained that it doesn't have anything to do with that..There's a lot of players still in their technically first game here, that doesn't mean we can half down the possible scum list because "they're new".

So we can overlook someone joking about being mafia, using bad logic, putting themselves in the bad side of the spotlight, just because we can somehow take their word for it that they wouldn't act that way if they were really scum? This is wifom all the way, as scum-you could just take advantage of that

 

Innocent.

Is this referring to Crimson Reaper? Because in no way does Crimson Reaper look experienced, neither was the case last game. So why would we assume experience? He says he's played a few, but that doesn't mean he's well-practiced enough to be considered experienced after all. There are such things as having the wrong kinds of experience too, which you are well aware of.

As for Crimson himself, meh. His defence was over the top given what it stemmed from, but I've seen that exact line of reasoning from new town players who don't know how to deal with pressure, so I don't place much stock in it.

 

Still. If you just so you wont defend yourself anymore it doesnt look good newbie or not

 

Experience maybe be not the proper wording but I wanted to convey that he has played games elsewhere from this site as per his own submission so it is not case completely new to mafia.
I guess not newbie could be better term mm

 

But he is new, clearly. Case in point being that he doesn't know how to defend himself. Simply having played a few games doesn't just mean someone knows how to play optimally.

 

Not knowing how to defend yourself and not defending yourself are two very different things although it's such a fickle matter to focus on