Normal Game Thread Big Trouble in Little Salem

This unvote was not counted because it occurred 10 minute after the deadline.

 

The fact that nick and quick voted for prada screams scummy based on what I've seen, it's still unclear to me why you guys have lynched him. As for the lynch on me, I honestly would much rather lynch nick or quick. They seem to have an alliance of some sort. I wouldn't love voting for prada since he seems innocent, I guess I'll just have to vote for nick since he seems quite the suspect(rolefishing and susing prada for no reason).

 

It should be very obvious this is a Scum kill on Pout. He had good solid content. Could be a delayed kill or something. Looking over one of his posts now on a reread. Will look for clues as to who could have killed him.

 

You really think I make that kind of back and forth with Nick like that? LOL. That would be the Scum theatre of the year.

 

Yeah i think you would. I can't just rule it out.

 

FWIW, I think you are going to flip Town here. I don't see you unvoting Prada here and voting Nick as Scum. Its too bad more people are not voting, I really think Prada is Scum here. Convinient how one of the Prada voters ends up dead an hour or so from EOD. If I am the NK today, I encourage Town to lynch Prada.

 

@Prada you don't reply to my quotes. I don't know why you keep thinking ignoring you.

On top of that I never argued your meta. At least point that out to me. At most I said you were guns blazing on me for a joke post. Idk where that inclines anything to your meta.

CR you just amaze me with your back and forth on who you find scummy or not.

 

News flash, flip flopping is not Scummy.

 

Flip flopping is easy scummy? It's like he is just trying to adhere to everyone's opinions and follow like a lost puppy.

 

Quick convinced me that prada might be scum and so I'm taking a gamble.

 

So reads:

Town:

Globear
CR
Nick
Wowee

Town Lean:

Ratchet
Crimson Falcon

Null:

SHINTO
Crisp
Lord Maple
Bimbonium

Scum Lean:

Rot
Prada

 

Its a myth that flip flopping comes more from Scum. In my experience it comes more from Town. There is only a specific kind of player that flip flops more as Scum than Town and they are not at all a simple kind of read to make on that type of player.

 

Would stopped kills still show up in the write-up as failed? Pretty interesting that there wasn't another death in day 1

Well, I woke up to vote but wrote this before and fell too asleep to post;
On a summary of reads,
Quick's arguments are really very poor. He repeats points that have already been properly explained, his responses to which mostly boil down to "that's how I know it/ moi experience" without actually countering them directly. Aside from that, "Whelp, I forgot about Ratchet's vote" is an absurd reason to get someone you town-read lynched day 1. While I am able to reluctantly justify some of his logic with 'ses experience', the voting switch seemed too silly for it to be simply confused-town Quick.
I'm sort of in the same mindset with CR, except that CR's defend buddies make him a more valuable lynch. Even without his back and forth with CF-Ningen early on, his more recent vote for Ningen is really just him contradicting himself on the lynch. New or not, falling to bad actions instead of just bad responses and defense is outside of town behavior.
On people that pushed the Ningen lynch more with prada and ratchet, I feel like most of the ratchet and ningen arguments were a found excuse to poke at ningen about something that can justify him being scum. A big part of their disagreement was finding out if Ningen was or wasn't referring to cr as a shit- which, lie or not, is pretty trivial to be properly scummy.. especially considering that Ratchet has played with him before and that type of behavior is fairly normal for Ningen, there should have probably been more leeway.
With Prada, his group up on day 1 was off-putting with the way Ningen flipped and CR acted, but with that being overshadowed by them being against each other in the lynch, I don't have much of a reason for suspicion on him. Didn't like the way he defended himself to early votes, but some reactions to avoid getting lynched strike me as town hope more than anything. While CR voting for Prada is just depending on quick's view on it

 

Sadly, CR, I think you are dead unless we get two voters for Prada, which sucks because I think you are Town and Prada is Scum.

 

I actually agree with your read on me. I have played very poorly this game.