1. Hey, Guest! Do you want to chat with us? Then come to the chat thread Here!
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Welcome to Sugoi Desu, Respected Guest! Please take a moment to register today.

Suggestion Contest voting to scale to participants

Discussion in 'Solved / Implemented' started by Ningen, Jun 24, 2017.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Ningen NIngenest of them all

    Messages
    517
    238
    Trophy Points
    360
    Keno
    11,356ლ
    Are you for real rn?

    How is 10 = 3
    AOTW and GFX comps arent just for Prizes, they are for self improvement- How can you know you improved when you got no votes or just 1-2 cuz someone made exceptional and stole all votes?
     
    Jus likes this.
  2. JoeJoe

    JoeJoe from the east blue

    Messages
    36,989
    16,920
    Trophy Points
    5,940
    Keno
    59,428ლ
    If you get 3 votes and get second place...it's the same if you get 10 votes and get second place.Second place is second place.

    Look...it has always been like that.Never been any problems.

    This is not OJ and it never will be OJ.

    Basically if you get 0 votes it means you need to learn.If someone with one vote CHOOSE you then it means he is happy with your work.
     
  3. Gobb finds a way

    Messages
    52,791
    28,608
    Trophy Points
    6,440
    Keno
    57,350ლ
    Votes don't make you better. There's literally an entire section users can post in, where they can get feedback, which is probably a better way than an anonymous contest. If you feel that the voting is incorrect for this contest, specific to numbers of entries, feel free to go post a suggestion.
     
  4. Ningen NIngenest of them all

    Messages
    517
    238
    Trophy Points
    360
    Keno
    11,356ლ
    >not OJ

    who brought OJ up?This is how every GFX forum goes
    Want me to link 20 different forums that go this way?
    Want me to tell that every single person has been doing it wrong for years like wow

    It has never been a problem because no one ever brought it up
    and whats the response when someone brought it up? But its always the same.

    When was last time you got 9 entries?
    Last AOTW was 2 entries.

    and that last line is perfect way to make people and especially beginners not take part in comp.
     
    Jus likes this.
  5. Ningen NIngenest of them all

    Messages
    517
    238
    Trophy Points
    360
    Keno
    11,356ლ
    Votes are motivation source for beginners. Anonymous is always better to see what water you are in.
    I did suggest it in first post tho that it should be 3 for 9
    1/3rd of entries is only valid for a person to make choice.


    Its not like Im suggesting something special
    This is what the norms are all over the internet.
     
    Jus likes this.
  6. EvilGenius I like potatoes

    Messages
    187
    78
    Trophy Points
    240
    Keno
    8,561ლ
    You have 9 entries i can bet you that by the end of it there will be 4 with 0 votes and 1-2 with 1 votes while 1 will be way ahead and 1 will be with 1/3 of the 1st place votes and be second.

    You get 3 likes means you can vote for 3 best entries there making it as people getting some kind of achievement of doign what they did and wanting to strive for more. There is a reason people get payed for doing work cause they need some way to strive, just some get payed less but all get payed in some way for what they did. You don't need to give half or more votes just 1/3.

    It's not about votes making you better it's about getting some accomplishment from it. In the end the best will still win but even those that didn't do well will have some votes and will see people appreciate what they did in some way giving them the power to strive to get better and climb.
     
    Rohan likes this.
  7. JoeJoe

    JoeJoe from the east blue

    Messages
    36,989
    16,920
    Trophy Points
    5,940
    Keno
    59,428ლ
    So we need to bandwagon everyone? cheers.

    I never got 9 entries when there weren't enough people to begin with.If I said my real feelings towards current AOTW then it would be a bigger mess so don't tempt me.

    I won't beg you for submitions it's your free will if you want to participate or not.All in all if you are beginner you will never do as good avatar as someone who is doing it daily.You learn you get better...points on AOTW should never be something to rely on since it's people opinions anyways.
     
  8. JoeJoe

    JoeJoe from the east blue

    Messages
    36,989
    16,920
    Trophy Points
    5,940
    Keno
    59,428ლ
    In the end if you get enough points for second and third you'll get second and third place.Be it one point,2 points or million points.

    Avatar which is second and third worthy will end second and third.
     
  9. JoeJoe

    JoeJoe from the east blue

    Messages
    36,989
    16,920
    Trophy Points
    5,940
    Keno
    59,428ლ
    What's the point of entering the contest if it's not a will to win.

    Then that's your personal problem not mine.
     
  10. Gobb finds a way

    Messages
    52,791
    28,608
    Trophy Points
    6,440
    Keno
    57,350ლ
    I said a thread, not a post in this thread. It'll only probably get buried after this thread is archived.

    Sure, more votes is good for getting more votes, but not for improvement. People aren't really giving constructive feedback or criticism in contests. Contest votes can be placed by any user on the website. They are not marking against specific criteria related to graphics. Half of the users may be pro on a website, half of them may not have a clue. Does it make sense that votes improve a person's ability to create? It doesn't really. I'm not saying to not make more votes. I'm not saying it's wrong to want more for encouragement. But, to gauge a persons ability, or capability on votes for a contest for fun is someone, err.. Dunno, contests are for fun and if you want to display work and seek for improvement, it seems better to post in the section where you will get the appropriate acknowledgement?
     
  11. Ningen NIngenest of them all

    Messages
    517
    238
    Trophy Points
    360
    Keno
    11,356ლ
    "Bandwagon"

    You take nice points from others and incorporate to make self better not cuz everyone does it so we wont.

    Just because everyone has military in world wont make a country be like lol nope too bandwagon no forces.

    Yes and I told you because you got its fair to adjust, You adjust accordingly as comp moves.

    Lemme tell you what - Hosts are meant TO ENCOURAGE PEOPLE to take part and and grow not you arent good so you shouldnt care anyway.
    GFX Is done for people opinion, Might be a shocker. Who would have known, People create art for others to like.
     
  12. EvilGenius I like potatoes

    Messages
    187
    78
    Trophy Points
    240
    Keno
    8,561ლ
    How can something that is worth 2nd or 3rd be there if all vote for the other one? Lmao you don't make sense. Basically what you want is a competition where there is Upper class the Rich one for whom all care and the bottom the poor one for whom no one gives a ****. That's what the current system is doing.
     
  13. Ningen NIngenest of them all

    Messages
    517
    238
    Trophy Points
    360
    Keno
    11,356ლ
    So basically you are saying this is for elitists
    If you can't win you can **** off

    Neat , Great to know.
    No point in continuing here anymore.
     
    Jus likes this.
  14. JoeJoe

    JoeJoe from the east blue

    Messages
    36,989
    16,920
    Trophy Points
    5,940
    Keno
    59,428ლ
    AOTW = Avatar of the Week AKA Best avatar.

    If you can't win you can learn.

    AOTW is not a feedback contest.You can get feedback from literally any thread in GFX.

    The point of contest is to show your best and choose best.

    But it doesn't that's the point not everyone will vote for one certain avatar :)
     
  15. Gobb finds a way

    Messages
    52,791
    28,608
    Trophy Points
    6,440
    Keno
    57,350ლ
    I thought you said that more votes are for people to improve? Or do you just mean as to encourage people?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page